Are College Rankings Problematic?

Colleges ranking systems and lists have been around since the first colleges were established. The demand for rankings is as pervasive as ever in the US. Each year, private companies publish college rankings. However, much like rankings for the “best jobs,” the “best movies of all time,” or the “greatest songs of all time,” they are highly subjective and they do not often reflect the interests, needs, or preferences for every student or applicant. Simply because a job is listed on Money Magazine’s list of “America’s Best Jobs” does not mean that we should all pursue a career in dentistry. The ranking of colleges are designed in much the same way.

For example, US News’ methodology in determining their college ranking list is based on categories such as retention of students, alumni donations, and graduation rates, while placing significant weight on the opinions of individuals who are in the position to evaluate a school’s academic excellence, such as provosts, presidents, and other individuals with vested interests in the institution. However, these quantitative measures do not consider the many other factors that are equally important in college decision-making, such as the availability of financial aid, the range of academic courses offered, and the location and the vibe of campus life. Rankings do not take into consideration more qualitative measures, and therefore, they are as subjective and as varied in their nuances as rankings for the “best” jobs and movies. Similarly, in establishing lists and rankings for colleges, we may very much disagree on what qualities constitute a place in such standings. Due to its nature of subjectivity, when referring to college rankings and lists, we must ask ourselves, “What do these rankings really reveal about colleges? Will they help me to find a college that caters to my interests and pursuits?”

Asking yourself what the college can offer you is the first step in unlocking the truth to how a college will maximize YOUR potential. Finding the right college fit is ever more important than looking at a ranking system. It is important that you do not rely solely on rankings when choosing a school.  

We encourage our parents and students to consider creating your own college list where you determine the ranking order, taking into account the aspects about college that matter most to your child. Then, begin to research schools that fit your criteria. This exercise will be a great way to begin the conversation about the college process with your child. At Mill Creek Academy, our focus is all about the right college fit! Don’t forget to check our College Admissions Consulting Packages to help your child find their college matches.